Marki Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 Set 1: I just think that it's really boring, no offence. The first is great, but the other 2 IMO are just not for me. Yes which one did you mean to vote for 2 or 4? it probably would of helped if you had explained your vote more.
MarMar Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 Can "really boring" count as constructive criticism?!
-Annie- Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 ^Yeah? Lots of people have said that, but what do they mean? More colour, text, brushes, sparkles?!...
Marki Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 Can "really boring" count as constructive criticism?! I think saying its boring is okay but i think that they need to explain why they think its more boring than the other so like if that person doesn't add more critisim to there vote it wont be counted
ldscott Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 This is really hard as I love them both but my vote is: Set 4- I think that the 1st 2 avs look a little dram like and so aren't as clear, the 3rd one looks too glittery and sharp in parts.
Amir Posted September 21, 2006 Report Posted September 21, 2006 #4- Well, the first one looks a little bit too shiny, don't know, it just doesn't look right. On the second, everything is fine, although the brush lets it down. The third is my fave out of this set. Everything is done well. -(Same reasons as before).
Marki Posted September 22, 2006 Report Posted September 22, 2006 Congrats to Set2 and Liz for coming first and congrats to everyone who entered they were all great. Runner up was sevenpuddings with set 4 Third place was- Mercury_Girl with Set 5 Nim with Set 8 fourth place was- Amir with Set 9 furrylogic with Set 6 fith place was- -Emily- with Set 1 princess_jessik with Set 10 sixth place was- flutterby with Set 3 aejdude with Set 7
princess_jessik Posted September 23, 2006 Report Posted September 23, 2006 Congratulations Liz! It was such a had choice but your icons are amazing & you definately deserved it. And congratulations Jess for comming second. Congratulations to everyone else who also entered. All the enteries was of an amazingly high standard. Looking forward to the start of the next competition......
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.