LIMS Archive

[Liz]

First round closes 20th October at 10pm UK time.

Vote for the two icon sets you like the least.

3.

10.

[~Amy~]

Set 2 and 9. Reasons: set number 2 looks too "busy". There's the darkness of it then the pinkness of it. Set number 9 doesn't look finished it looks like its misssing something. But they are still really good.

[.Cat.]

8. I like the first one, but not really the coloring. I think it needs to be a bit more vibrant. The second one, good cropping! I like the text, but maybe a different font. It's also a bit too dark, but I don't know, that could be what the person was aiming for...The third one, again good cropping, and I love the coloring/idea, but it's just way too dark!

6. I like the idea of the first one But a think the white line just does something to ruin it. I think it's a little to thick, or something. And I think Zoe is a little too orange. The second one, to be honest, I don't really like those kind of icons that have that polaroid brush thing on it. Some look ok, though. But anyway, reason being is because it cuts off part of whoevers face e.t.c. The text is nice. I like the font, but maybe something different would suit more. The third, I like the cropping, but I think it's just a little too dark. I think the red thingy should be placed by the persons hand, and then the tiny text underneath. The tiny text is a little too bold, aswell.

On a positive note, I love 1, 2, 3, 10, and 12.

[*belle*]

8. I think the icons all had good idea's behind them but I don't really like the way that they turned out. The colouring doesn't do much for them and I don't like the way that the text is wrapped around parts of the picture. I've got to say I think that the last one is to dark and maybe even the second one. But none of them are really bad!

4. I don't like the fonts used on the text or where the text has been positioned. I'm also not a big fan of the colouring on any of these, especially the last one. I think that the first one would have been much better without the colour blob (sorry, I don't know what it's called) in the middle and the second one could have been made more vibrant. Again though, none of them are bad!

I love number 5, 6 and 10 though.

[MarMar]

1: The cropping is nice, but the coloring doesn't go. Also, the monochrome/green icon is too bland.

5: 2 of the icons go so well together, but the first just stands out like a sore thumb. It doesn't live up to the others.

[angelgirl]

4:Because in the 3rd icon the colour of the text and the colour of the pic don't go together atall!The Drew one,the pic is not very good quality and the text is not seen very well!And the first one is a bit plain.

9:Because the 1st one Jacks face is not seen very well and it is a bit plain.The 3rd one the pic is a bit close and a bit plain really.I love the 2nd one though

[Liz]

Number 12 added, because somebody forgot to check their email inbox.

If anybody wants to change their votes, feel free.

[Amir]

#6- On the first one, I like the colouring on Lucas, but the colouring on Zoe is just, burnt. I really don't like the layout, and the idea of the 2nd icon, it seems a little unusual. Although, the third one is awesome!

#9- The first has pretty blant colouring, it's a little too dark too. On the 2nd icon, it doesn't need that text. It basically ruins the icon. The last one is great! Just a little more contrast could look better.

[iloverobbie]

2 - The croping is great and even though its black and white the colouring is good, if that makes sence.

11 - Good croping as well, I espically like the colouring on the kim one and the brushes on the 1st one.

[sevenpuddings]

#8 - I like the colouring and cropping of the first icon, but I'm not a fan of the way the text is set out. The second icons is alright, a little pink though. The third, the colouring, for me, is all over the place. Too dark and too light, all in the same icon, and I'm not a fan of the brown colouring either.

# 9 - The first icon, the blending isn't done too well, and the picture just feels empty. The second feels too bright, a little less contrast might have worked better. The third on the other hand, feels as though there isn't enough contrast, like the face should stand out more.