LIMS Archive

[sevenpuddings]

#10 - same as before.

#2 - I like the idea that they've gone with for all to be B&W but it doesn't show much versilatility at all. I like the first, the second needs more contrast, the colouring is a little off and the white boarder needs to be bigger to cover more of the space and cut off the edge. And the third is too contrasted which detracts from the icon.

[burr]

No. 10 and No. 11. I don’t think either work as well as complete sets as the first two. 10. The first icon is nice but nothing special, neither the cropping or the colouring are amazing and perhaps some effects or text would have been nice.

No. 11 all 3 are good but as a set they don’t fit together all that well. The first one I’m not sure about the choice of pic, Irene looks kinds of ridiculous! The Kim one is nice but it’s not really pushing any boundaries, perhaps if it had been a little more daring with some effects or something that would have been cool.

[-Emily-]

#2, they are too b&w. They need at lest some colour on the people. I don't know why, but they seem to overdone.

#11. The first ones text doesn't suit. It kinda ruins the hole concept of the icon. The second seems too blue and in your face. Although everything about the third, rocks!

[Liz]

We have a tie! I need a deciding vote!

[Marieh]

#2 & #11

Reasons:

#2

I really like the first and the last one, but they're kinda boring in the end, and I can't really get what they're about so it's confusing because I don't know what's happening. The 2nd one is to yellow.

#11

The first one is really godd and I'd never use that picture because I've never seen it before. The 2nd picture is also to yellow, and I don't really like the brush that's been used on the last one, but I do like the colouring.

God I hate this . But someone have to do it.

And I really like #3, who ever made that:

GREAT job!

[Eli]

10. - I don't like the green/purple stuff, I think it messes up the clean pictures.

11. - Even though I love the last one, I don't think this is enought to keep it in the competition, I think the coloring on no. one and two is good, but unfortunately not as good as the others.

[furrylogic]

#10 - The first icon is kinda washed out, and it detracts from the picture, because the cropping is nice. I'm not a fan of the border crossing her head on the third icon, it makes the avatar look a bit funny. It looks as if you couldn't decide which desaturated image to use so you went for the same effect, and it takes away from the unique effect of having one image the way you did it.

#3 - The first two have a huge pink tinge, and they all seem a bit pixalated. I like the cropping on the second, but I feel that it needs to be a bit more contrasted. The cropping of the third is nice, but it feels all together too blue, and may have benefitted from being a bit lighter.

That was hard.

[Liz]

Thanks to Marie's deciding vote, sets 2 and 11 have been eliminated.

Final Round

Vote for the one avatar you like the most, stating reaons why. Voting ends 26th November, 10pm, UK time.

[*belle*]

10 - I like the simplicity of it, especially the first one. I think they stand out more than the other set, which to me look a bit busy, and the colours are nice and vibrant.

[Marieh]

#3

I really like the first avatar, and the cropping is really good, and the moment is just so great captured!, the 2nd one I'm not really sure about who it is *soory, hides* but I really like that it's so mystical and he looks really good in that picture! The 3rd one is really good, I love the way the text have been writed and the font is really great.

#10 is also a great set!

I really like you're first icon, but the 2nd and the 3rd one looks to similar that it takes the attention from each other and I just loose the icons really.

So my vote goes to #3

And all of you all should be proud of your work, and I also mean the people who've been voted off, there was some really great icons this time!

ETA: I forgot that I only was suppose to pick one, but does my vote still count?