sevenpuddings Posted December 14, 2006 Report Posted December 14, 2006 #6 - The cropping is nice, but the colouring feels a little to dark for a scene that is supposed to be vibrant and full of love. The second avatar also feels a little blurry for my liking, and overall they feel plain, like something is missing. - I really love #5 though, the use of the song in that moment was risky, as it may only have appealed to major season one OC fans, but I think it works really well! And the colouring of #3 is fabulous too! Its different, and a little harsher in places, which works really well for the story you're trying to tell.
SfanS Posted December 14, 2006 Report Posted December 14, 2006 Ummmm....... They were all quite good, but... I didn't really like no. 3 that much... I found the third picture a bit faraway, , and I didn't think it looked veryu good in greyscale. Closer, maybe, but not like that. Just my personal opinion.... But I LOVED 1and2! Winnie the Pooh!!
Eli Posted December 14, 2006 Report Posted December 14, 2006 I think many of them are good, but the one I like least is number 4, simply because I don't understand the story they are supposed to tell.
ms.megan Posted December 15, 2006 Report Posted December 15, 2006 I'll have to vote for #4 The story that the icons are trying tell isn't very clear, and I actually have no idea what it is about. Also I think the pictures are too small. However I really like #1 and #2, they are great.
-Tess- Posted December 15, 2006 Report Posted December 15, 2006 4- I don't get how the last one fits into the story...They look great, but I don't get what 42 has to do with everything...
burr Posted December 15, 2006 Report Posted December 15, 2006 6. The colouring is a little dark, it lack's vibrancy. The cropping and choice of pics is also a little predictable, and the last one the cropping is too central. Just have to say I love 4 although it seems no once else does! They are all so interesting and they just keep growing on me.
MarMar Posted December 19, 2006 Report Posted December 19, 2006 Sorry for being late, I completely forgot! We'll have to say bye to set no.4 Please vote on the two sets you like the least - voting ends at noon on Thursday (GMT)
-Tess- Posted December 19, 2006 Report Posted December 19, 2006 6 - I feel it's a bit plain, and a bit over coloured. 3 - For me, the colours are too bright, and I don't like how one is black and white, while the others aren't.
ms.megan Posted December 19, 2006 Report Posted December 19, 2006 5 and 6- Mainly because I am over the Seth and Summer thing, and I am over the OC.I also think that set 6 is rather plain.
princess_jessik Posted December 19, 2006 Report Posted December 19, 2006 ^^ Umm ... I think you are ment to vote on the actual icon technically (ie. cropping/colouring) not whether you like or dislike the Seth/Summer relationship or whether you are "over" the OC or not. Anyway my votes: 2. I don't really like the colouring on the first icon, too me it's too harsh. Also I don't particularly like the stripy white textures used on all the icons ... I feel they are distracting. And the text in the third icon is a little too hard to read. I like the second icon however. Goshh this is hard .... 5. Firstly, I don't really like the text. It just seems abit off in placement in both the first and second icons. And the colouring of the second icon is abit too dark imo. However, I love that this icon maker has used three different colourings on the three different icons. I also like the third icon, the red circle texture gives a nice effect. I hope I wasn't too harsh ... I just had to be picky because all those icons are gorgeous!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.