sevenpuddings Posted January 11, 2007 Report Posted January 11, 2007 #4 - All three are lacking a bit in contrast. I like the cropping on the first, but can't help and feel that another brush/different text and placement of it may have made it look better. The second, I feel, could have done better without the brush on the bottom, and the third feels very empty. I think it might be cropped too far away. #3 - I'm not exactly sure whats going on in the first icon - it seems very blurred, which makes her all mould into a kinda of, blob (her hands especially) - and the colouring feels very yellow and black, not very eye catching - same with the third, its empahsised the yellow a bit too much, and I think shes giving someone the finger, but it kind of, moulds into the background. The third is alright, but I think the text needs to stand out a little more rather than be shoved in a corner. - On the plus side, I adore #8 - Only male entrant, plus the icons are stunning, each is different, but the colouring + text are constant on each! Beautiful work!
-Emily- Posted January 11, 2007 Report Posted January 11, 2007 #3:- The first one seems kinda blurry, the second icon is really dull, it needs saturation uppage. The third is nice though. #4:- The brush doesn't go on the first, like its too bold and 'in your face'. I like the second! The third, is a bit too, over sharpened, and the colouring is a bit off. I absolitely adore #9 though, gorgeous, colouring!
.Cat. Posted January 11, 2007 Report Posted January 11, 2007 3. Like Jess said, I don't really understand what's going on in the first icon. The colouring looks a bit weird. I'm not too sure on the font used either. The second icon, I think would of looked btter without any text, as it sort of distracts you from the main focus. The third icon looks a bit creepy...her eyes look black (it could just be the darkness of my computer, though). 4. I like the feeling on the first one, but I don't really like the brush- I think it's the big gaps between the words. The second is a bit too light, and I don't really like the border. On the third one, the vibrancy of the dress is a bit distracting, and I don't really like the border either. Some text might've been nice. I LOVE number 5, however.
ms.megan Posted January 12, 2007 Report Posted January 12, 2007 #1.I think that each individual icon should have it's own style and in this set, whereas these icons are practically all the same. I think that the base does not work properly with the first icon as the image is rather bright and the base is dull, i don't think they work well together. For icons two and three they are almost the same the only differences are that the images are different and there is another brush used in the third icon. In icons two and three I also find that the floral brush covers parts of Ashley's face. #3.I cannot quite understand what the picture is in the first icon. It has been blurred to much and is now sort of like a big blob of colours. With icon number two the word "pose" looks a bit jumbled, with p&o being lower then s&e, I think it would have looked better in a straight line. Also the image seems a bit pixelated and not very smooth. In icon number three i think that the choice of picture wasn't the wisest, Avril looks evil as her eyes are rather black looking. I also think that yellow has been emphasized to much and her hand which i believe she is doing the ups has blended into the background.
furrylogic Posted January 13, 2007 Report Posted January 13, 2007 Sorry I forgot to say the first two sets will be elimated 7pm AEST Sunday 14th.
~Angel~ Posted January 13, 2007 Report Posted January 13, 2007 I'm saying #1- The person ahs used the same background on all the av's and the white stuff covering ashley's face is very annoying, because you can't really see her face. #3- The colouring is a bit dull and I don't quite understand what it's about.
furrylogic Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 Sets #3 and #4 have been elimated. Please vote for the next two sets you like least. And remember to be clear in your voting. This round will end 7pm Tuesday 16th Jan
-Tess- Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 1- I don't like the bruses or colouring used on these, and i think that the colours could be mixed a bit better. 2 - I don't like the cropping on these ones, along with the colour on the 1st one.
sevenpuddings Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 2 - Not really sure the colouring on the first - the green and purple seem to clash. The second, the centered cropping is perfect, but the colouring feels too dark, but not contrasted enough at the same time. The third, the colouring is interesting - but I don't really like it. I feel that this one lacks a bit of contrast too. 1 - As much as I think the cropping on these is amazing, I think everything else kind of, lacks - the colouring doesn't feel vibrant, the pictures don't feel contrasted enough, and they seem kind of, lacking, overall. Sorry.
-Emily- Posted January 14, 2007 Report Posted January 14, 2007 #2- The cropping and colouring looks...strange? The cropping is a bit dull also. The colouring is a bit light on the icons, like too many screen layers. I really dislike the cropping as well. Sorry. I love set 1, why does everyone keep voting it out?! Its really nice and unique!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.