.Cat. Posted March 13, 2007 Report Posted March 13, 2007 4- This set didn't really catch my eye. For the first icon: I think it would've looked better without the J. The cropping is nice, but I think it could use some colouring. For the second icon: I like the idea, but I don't think the font was the best choice, and the lines are kind of tacky. But as said before, the idea of it is really unique. For the third icon: The cutting on the first picture isn't really good, and I just don't feel as if they go together. 5- For the first icon: Betty! I think the cropping is a little too close up, and I don't really like the gradient. For the second icon: I feel as though the text is kind of distracting- I think the icon might of looked better without any text. I also think it shouldn't have a border. For the third icon: I like this one. The only faults are that I think the Maddie picture could have been lighted/coloured, and a different font should've been used. Other than that, I LOVE set 2!
Cerise Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 #5 - As Cat said, the cropping on the first Icon is too close up. I don't like the Gardient either. On the Second the Border looks out of Place and the font is a bit disturbing and big. #6 - The lighting and brushes on the first two dont look nice, and they cover up the faces and I dont really like the coloring on the third either. Sorry, but good work all of you. I feel like a bitch
rockagirl Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 #5 - Like the other people said the Betty cropping is to close and way to light on the "glamour girl" text.. Also the text on the Tasha one is to much and the colouring is a bit to light.. Also its just weird on the third with Matilda and Seth.. Like out of the blue.. #6 - All the icons are way to light and its to much on the Matilda one. The brush is also a bit out of the blue on the Matilda one..
dsingles Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 All the icon's are great and I hate to have to do this here it goes... No. 4 - The cropping is great on the first icon but it's just not very eye-catching. The second one is a little too close. The third could have been blended better the edges are a little too sharp. No. 8 - The first one is great, the second one just wasn't very eye-catching and I didn't really understand the different emotions in the third one. Congrats to everyone on all there hard work xxx
flutterby Posted March 14, 2007 Report Posted March 14, 2007 4- This set didn't really catch my eye. For the first icon: I think it would've looked better without the J. The cropping is nice, but I think it could use some colouring. For the second icon: I like the idea, but I don't think the font was the best choice, and the lines are kind of tacky. But as said before, the idea of it is really unique. For the third icon: The cutting on the first picture isn't really good, and I just don't feel as if they go together. 5- For the first icon: Betty! I think the cropping is a little too close up, and I don't really like the gradient. For the second icon: I feel as though the text is kind of distracting- I think the icon might of looked better without any text. I also think it shouldn't have a border. For the third icon: I like this one. The only faults are that I think the Maddie picture could have been lighted/coloured, and a different font should've been used. Other than that, I LOVE set 2! My thoughts exactly...and I'm too lazy to write practically the same thing in my own words
Eli Posted March 15, 2007 Report Posted March 15, 2007 #4 - I think the first icon is the best, but it is a bit boring. I don't really like the cropping in the second one, and the blending could have been better in the third icon. #5 - I don't really like the font used in these icons. Also the gradient is a bit too strong in the first one. I don't think the contrasts on the two images you have used in the third icon go with each other, but other than that I like it.
aejdude Posted March 15, 2007 Report Posted March 15, 2007 First Round: Voting closed. Sets 4 and 5 eliminated. Second Round: Vote for the next TWO sets you like the LEAST. The two sets with the most votes will be eliminated on Saturday 17 March 5PM GMT.
princess_jessik Posted March 16, 2007 Report Posted March 16, 2007 6 - I am not a fan of the colouring/texture used in the first icon. The colouring is over powering and over Tasha's face. I'm not overly a fan of the text placement in the image and the texture used on the background. I do like the third icon however, the text is nice. The pictures are also different because Martha is crying & Jack is happy. 8 - Like the colouring of this first icon but i don't really like how the text is over Pete's face. Also not overly a fan of the text on the second icon. The third icon is really nice, but I'm not a fan of the black border around the three icons. Sorry ... my reasons aren't overly amazing it was hard. All the icons are of amazing quality. I especially LOVE set 2!! Great job to everyone!
dsingles Posted March 16, 2007 Report Posted March 16, 2007 No. 8 - The first one is great, the second one just wasn't very eye-catching and I didn't really understand the different emotions in the third one, not sure it really fits. No. 3 - I quite like the colouring but it's all a little bit samey, would have been great to see a bit more variety within the three. Great work everyone and good luck.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.