dsingles Posted March 21, 2007 Report Posted March 21, 2007 It's getting really hard to be critical when they are all soo good, but here it goes...... No. 3 - I quite like the colouring but it's all a little bit samey, would have been great to see a bit more variety within the three. No. 1 - They don't look as professional, they aren't as eye catching and the colouring is not as interesting. Well done and good luck xxx
Eli Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 #1 I just don't find them very interesting and eye catching. Also I don't really like the frame on the first icon. #3 I like the effect, but it gets a bit boring when they're that much like each other. Also I don't think the smalles image in the last icon works very well. Sorry, I hate to do this, but I had to choose
aejdude Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 Round three now comes to a close. Sets 1 and 3 have been eliminated. THE FINALE: Vote for the set you like the BEST. The set with the most votes will win. Voting will close on Saturday 24th March 1pm GMT.
~Dom~ Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 7- I think you can see the emotions are more visible in the last avatar becuase in 2 I think the last both people look upset Also I really like the colouring, But I still love number 2 I don't like doing this
~Charlotte~ Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 #2 The style looks great and you can really see the emotions, especially in the first avatars and i like how they used a range of cropping which makes i look even more fantastic!
~Amy~ Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 Set #2. Fantastic set! The first icon; the cropping is stunning! Just love the angle on it. The colouring is also brilliant. It just looks amazing! The Second Icon; I really like the sytle! The colouring and the font both complement each other. The Third; I love how you've chosen one (hilarious) picture to display the two emotions. The colouring is nice & I really like the cropping. Set #7. I think the cropping is nice in all three but a little too "on the safe side", if you get me...? Like how they're all kinda to the right. The first; I like the colouring is great, subtle but still eyecatching kind of thing. The wording is great too, I'm just not too sure on the font... The second; I think the font is a tad too big/close to Ric. Its kinda distracting, (IMO). I'm not too keen on the glow around it either. Maybe it would look better with less/no text...? The third; This is a great icon! I actually liked this best out of everyone's 3rd icon. The text is great, and I love how Ellie is fading; ties in with the subject. I really adore this one but I feel the first two kind of let it down. So my vote goes to set number Seven. I know I was picky but I had to choose someone. Both are great and totally deserve to be in the final round.
flutterby Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 Set number four Amy?! lol I like set 1 the best, the colouring is great and I like the use of pictures and cropping.
~Amy~ Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 Urgh figures are not my strong point. Edit: Seems they're not yours either. Set one was eliminated.
flutterby Posted March 22, 2007 Report Posted March 22, 2007 lol That was a complete accident! I meant I liked set 2 the best, for the reasons stated.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.