flutterby Posted April 7, 2007 Report Posted April 7, 2007 #4 - The first is really sweet, I don't really like the way the texture has been used in the second, and I'm not sure about the placement of the text in the third. #7 - I actually really like this set and my reasons are kind of picky... love the second and third ones, the first, I think a bit more could've been done with the text, perhaps lowered the opacity or a glow? The repeated image is a little bit lost too.
Nim Posted April 7, 2007 Report Posted April 7, 2007 Need more votes to eliminate two people tonight.
-Karen- Posted April 8, 2007 Report Posted April 8, 2007 This is a really really really tough one! I apologise but I'm going to have to pick out very minor things. #4 - I really like the first icon, particularly the colouring, but I think the smaller text is way too small and the very thin strip on the left side is unnecessary. I feel the text is too small on the second icon and the texture is fighting against the main image, rather than working with it. Also, at first glance it looks like Tasha is about to be taken out by a twister! As for the third icon, I think it's great and have nothing bad to say about it at all! #7 - I love the cropping, text and vibrant colouring on the first icon but the repeated image looks a bit odd mixed up in her hair. Interesting use of the texture in the second but I'm not too keen on the double image thing. I like the third icon but it is missing something, possibly some text or a brush.
Cerise Posted April 9, 2007 Report Posted April 9, 2007 #1: I don't like the little Circle-Repeated Image thingie or the Coloring/Text on the Second. I like the third though #7: The first Image looks weird, and I don't like the Coloring on the second. And on the third I don't like the Grey
~Charlotte~ Posted April 10, 2007 Report Posted April 10, 2007 1# I don't really think it looks good when they placed a smaller picture in a circle border, i think it looks rather messy. In the second avatar, i think that the texture doesn't really look good, because of the way they used it. Other than that i really like the last one. #7 The first one is quite good, but her mouth does not really look like it is in the right place. Again in the seond avatar for this set, i really don't like the way the texture has been used. In the last, i think it would have been better if it was cropped a different way, maybe more to the right.
Nim Posted April 10, 2007 Report Posted April 10, 2007 Third Round: Voting closed. Sets 1 and 7 are eliminated. Final Round: Vote for your favourite set. Winner will be announced on Wednesday 11 April 6PM GMT.
aejdude Posted April 12, 2007 Report Posted April 12, 2007 #4 - each icon is different, when compared to 3 where they are all the same style. I love the third icon, fab colouring and cropping. Interesting colouring on second, although the texture is a bit overwhelming. Seen so many icons that have the style icon one has so not so impressed with that one it looks a bit faded nevertheless vote goes to 4.
~Charlotte~ Posted April 12, 2007 Report Posted April 12, 2007 4# Like aaron said, in this set they all have a different style, which makes this set stand out the more than the other set. In the first av, it looks very unique and has good colouring. In the second av, i really like how they have used the texture, and it really goes with the pic they have used. In the third av, it has great colouring and the text just finishes it off, really well. So therefore i am voting for #4
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.