sevenpuddings Posted June 28, 2007 Report Posted June 28, 2007 4: The first icon is great, except the colouring is too pink and saturated. I really like the cropping and text though. The second icon is very dark. The third is very original, although a bit yellow for my liking. Ick, this second one is hard. 5: I really like the cropping and colouring of the first icon, but feel the text overwhelms it. The second is nice, but too light, and the text doesn't contrast enough in my opinion. I like the b&w of the third, but feel its been a bit overwhelmed by the texture.
aejdude Posted June 28, 2007 Report Posted June 28, 2007 4. First icon is too pink, altho i do like the text placement. Second icon - Too dark, too busy and i don't like the crop. Third icon - Too yellow, not too keen on border, but text is okay. 5. First icon would look fine with no text, second icon would look better if it had more contrast and glowy text isn't the way to go on every single icon Third icon my favourite out of the set, although the icon would look so much better without the texture.
flutterby Posted June 28, 2007 Report Posted June 28, 2007 4 - I like the originality of the last, the first is a lot of the same colour and the second is a tad fuzzy. 5 - They're all pretty bad, the first has ok colouring but the text doesn't suit it, the last, although the subject is hotness itself doesn't suit the texture and the text placement isn't great, the middle one is not even worth discussing. Although I do agree with the artist's choices of topic, particularly the last mmmmmm.....
furrylogic Posted June 29, 2007 Report Posted June 29, 2007 Set #4 and set #5 have been elimated. Please vote for the set you like the most. Voting will end Sunday 1st July at 7pm AEST.
ali52 Posted June 30, 2007 Report Posted June 30, 2007 My Favourite is Set #2. I love the coloring used in the first and third ones, and the font you used them. great job
sevenpuddings Posted July 7, 2007 Report Posted July 7, 2007 Please vote for your two least favourite sets with comments as to why they are lesser quality in your opinion. Voting for this round will end Monday 9am AusEST. Set One: Set Two: Eliminated Set Three: Eliminated Set Four: Eliminated Set Five:
Jen Posted July 7, 2007 Report Posted July 7, 2007 This is tough - Set 2 - I really like the first icon however I don't think the cropping suits the second. The text placement is good and the brownish colouring I think is maybe a bit too dark. The colouring of the third is nice and bright however I don't like the repeating of the two images next to each other separated by the line. I don't think the text or line is necessary on this occassion. Set 3 - I really like how all the icons seem to match but I don't think the maroon border and text suits the colouring of the first and last icons. However I really like the cropping of the last and the text placement of the 2nd.
~Rosey~ Posted July 7, 2007 Report Posted July 7, 2007 All good entries But... Set 4 - As much as I love the first icon, Ithink the secondone is a tad too dark. I like the cropping of the third one but once again I think its too dark. Set 3 - I only really like the first one and I think the coloring suits it - and its cute. But I dont think that form of coloring suits the other two. I also the the boder is a tad to thick ------------ I feel mean now! Sorry
sevenpuddings Posted July 9, 2007 Report Posted July 9, 2007 Set Four Eliminated. Please vote for the two sets you like least. Voting will end Wednestday 11th 9am AUS EST.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.