dsingles Posted July 9, 2007 Report Posted July 9, 2007 All the entries are excellent but here it goes... Set 2: I like the first icon, the colouring is good but the band with the writing could have been smaller and the picture bigger. The cropping on the second icon is a harsh and I like the repeating on the third but I don't think the line is necessary and the text is a little small. Set 5: Again on the first one, the image could have been bigger or made more use of the white band cause it looks a little plain but I love the text it really suits. The second is alittle too blurry but I like the contrast and the pink glow but the text is a little small. The third is just a little plain with not much diffence to the original but I like the cropping. Sorry I feel awful now xxx
sevenpuddings Posted July 11, 2007 Report Posted July 11, 2007 Come on people! All I'm asking for is a line or two. I don't like the colouring, I don't like the text, it looks too squished. Thats it. Is it really that hard to vote?
ohsedateme Posted July 11, 2007 Report Posted July 11, 2007 Set Three - The icon maker clearly has a lot of talent but I don't like the borders, and that particular font only looks good on the second icon. Set Two - I love the first icon, there's not one thing wrong with it. But the second icon's text doesn't suit it and I don't like the white space inbetween on the third icon. Sorry guys, you have way more talent than I do but all's fair in an icon contest?
Jen Posted July 11, 2007 Report Posted July 11, 2007 Can I vote the same again? If so same reasons as below. This is tough - Set 2 - I really like the first icon however I don't think the cropping suits the second. The text placement is good and the brownish colouring I think is maybe a bit too dark. The colouring of the third is nice and bright however I don't like the repeating of the two images next to each other separated by the line. I don't think the text or line is necessary on this occassion. Set 3 - I really like how all the icons seem to match but I don't think the maroon border and text suits the colouring of the first and last icons. However I really like the cropping of the last and the text placement of the 2nd.
sevenpuddings Posted July 11, 2007 Report Posted July 11, 2007 You sure can Jen! Sets Two & Three have been eliminated. Please vote for your least favourite set with substancial reasons as to why.
~Rosey~ Posted July 19, 2007 Report Posted July 19, 2007 LIMS 13 Topics 1. Rachel 2. Villian 3. Teens Set 1 - Set 2 - Set 3 - Eliminated Set 4 - Eliminated Set 5 - Eliminated Set 6 - Eliminated Voting - Please vote for you 2 LEAST favourite. Will close Saturday Night, 8pm Aus time
sevenpuddings Posted July 19, 2007 Report Posted July 19, 2007 Set 3 - The crop on the first avatar seems off. There doesn't seem to be enough contrast in the second, and the third feels too dark. Set 6 - Each avatar feels overwhelmed by the use of textures, and I feel they don't leave enough room to portray the actual theme of the avatar enough.
aejdude Posted July 19, 2007 Report Posted July 19, 2007 Set 5 - Nice crop on first but colouring seems very washed out, hate crop on second and text doesn't suit it. However i like the last icon. Set 6 - I have to agree with Jess on this one. The textures don't do the avatars any favours at all. You can barely read the text, them all being b&w shows lack of creativity cutting out a little slice of the picture and putting it on a texture isn't very creative, b&w effect isn't effective here lacks contrast.
Cerise Posted July 19, 2007 Report Posted July 19, 2007 6 - I'll have to agree, I don't like the Textures, and the text doesn't suit. They are nice attempts though, but main Images are very hard to see 3 - I don't like the cropping on the first, it seems a bit dull. It doesn't stand out, because there's nothing unique to it. On the second, I don't like the cropping and there is not enough Contrast to make it stand out, and as it's black and white it too looks dull. The Text takes up a lot of space, the font does not work and the red I dun like. Third has okish Cropping, but is way too dark and the text looks a bit out there... Sorry, I'm a bitch. Feel free to lock me up and throw away the key
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.