Cerise Posted July 23, 2007 Report Posted July 23, 2007 Set Two: the Coloring and text (which is also very unreadable) seems very off and I really don't like the Cropping... The Icons have the same un-clearness about them and make them very alike. Set Five: First is too bright, has off-coloring and not enough Contrast. A border would make it stand out more as well. Third looks like it's only been cropped and have text (which does not suit the icon) added to it. The third is good, except for the Central Cropping.
Skykat Posted July 23, 2007 Report Posted July 23, 2007 Set 5: I'm not an artistic expert but I'm not a fan of the first one. It seems a bit pale and yellowy and the cropping is a bit off. I like the second one though I'm not sure the text does it justice and though I like the idea behind the third one, the colouring seems a bit off. Set 4: I love the first one, really love it but I think the second one is a bit pale, though the cropping and theme is good. The third one seems a bit yellowy but both are good efforts. Hope thats okay.
~Rosey~ Posted July 23, 2007 Report Posted July 23, 2007 Set 5 and 4 eliminated Please vote for the one you like the most This will end Thursday Morning, 8am
sevenpuddings Posted July 23, 2007 Report Posted July 23, 2007 Set 2. The colouring is really unique, as is the use of the same text plus scribble underneath, however there is just enough variation to make it work. The second avatar is just brilliant, the angle, text - everything is great!
lollipop_lover11 Posted July 24, 2007 Report Posted July 24, 2007 Set 2. I really like the text with the line underneath and I think that the cropping is pretty good.
Cerise Posted July 24, 2007 Report Posted July 24, 2007 Urm... this is very hard for me... but here is goes I vote Number one, because the first Icon has great contrast and I like the Cap used on the Third. I like the second, though a bit of CC; I think it would look better without the text I haven't gone with the crowd and voted for two, as I said before the Icons are too unclear, and the text very unreadable. (But what do I know? ) Vote goes to Number ONE Sorry if I sounded moody and bitchy btw, just not feeling great today
Zetti Posted July 24, 2007 Report Posted July 24, 2007 Set one because they dont all follow the same pattern with the Corey one in black and white.
aejdude Posted July 24, 2007 Report Posted July 24, 2007 Set 1 - Nice variety of cropping shown here. The colouring is nice, and the text suits the avatars. Would have voted for Set 2 but they are way too green for my liking.
~Rosey~ Posted July 25, 2007 Report Posted July 25, 2007 Sorry for the 3 minute delay! Results will be psoted in main thread
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.