Jen Posted August 4, 2007 Report Posted August 4, 2007 LIMS #14. Icon #1 - Favourite storyline of 2006 Icon #2 - The Hunter's Icon #3 - A Kiss Vote for the two sets of icons you like the least. Please give relevant/creative-based reasons for your votes. The Entries: Set 1 - *Eliminated* Set 2 - *Eliminated* Set 3 - Set 4 - Set 5 - *Eliminated*
~Rosey~ Posted August 4, 2007 Report Posted August 4, 2007 Set 2 - Either of the 3 icons stand out to me. It doesnt look like much work except for cropping has been done to them. Also if the black/white one was lighter, it would proberly look better Set 1 - For the first one, I'm not really sure what the story like is telling us, and it doesnt look like much work has been done. I do like the cap used. The second one is okay I guess but I think the text stands out abit to much. But I really do like the 3rd one Cropping is perfect. Sorry peoples xxx
sevenpuddings Posted August 4, 2007 Report Posted August 4, 2007 Set 1 - All three icons look rather like bases. They would look nicer if they were brighter and a little more vibrant. Set 2 - Again, they look something along the line of bases. They look pixelated, and the b&w isn't light or contrasted enough.
Cerise Posted August 4, 2007 Report Posted August 4, 2007 Here it goes... Set 1: These icons just look like they've been cropped and added text to them... There is nothing 'special' about them, I feel there is a lack of Contrast that could have made them stand out more Set 2: first Icon looks a bit sharp, again no major sign of coloring. The next 2 look like bases to me.... Set 3: I think I like this set. The only thing I'd say is the font 'Father and Son' is written in. But on the next Icon, 'farewell' is really well placed and looks great. And the coloring on the third is just great! Set 4: Wow. the first icon is just... mind blowing. I love the way 'broken' is on the icon three times - if that makes sense. The second looks great, has just the right contrast. I love the texture on the third, and the text works so well. Set 5: Ohh, the coloring on these three icons is great! But I hate the two people in the third icon... Votes go to 1 and 2
ali52 Posted August 4, 2007 Report Posted August 4, 2007 Set 1- It doesnt stand out and grab my attention and i dont like the texts. Set 2 - like #1 too plan, doesnt stand out for me and look like bases
Jen Posted August 7, 2007 Report Posted August 7, 2007 Sets 1 and 2 have been eliminated. Please vote for the one (1) set you like the least, with reasoning.
flutterby Posted August 7, 2007 Report Posted August 7, 2007 Set 5 - I'm not a fan of the cropping on the first, the second's cropping is ok but I think it would've been a bit better if her hairline was included. The faces look almost distorted by over blurring, particularly the second. I like the colouring on the last.
dsingles Posted August 8, 2007 Report Posted August 8, 2007 Set 5 - The first picture is a little bland, the second icon is great but the last is a little bit plain also. I think the icons would have been more interesting if one or two had text. The coloring is good but don't really match the mood the images give.
-Emily- Posted August 8, 2007 Report Posted August 8, 2007 Set 5 - The faces are too blurred - [The EyebrOws] I like the colouring on the first one though. xxx =]]
Cerise Posted August 8, 2007 Report Posted August 8, 2007 Set 5; Icons look a little boring and I don't love the cropping on the third... Great job though
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.