X Factor 2008

[jim6600]

agreed with the bottom two last night

but i think they should have judged it more on potential - and scott has much more than daniel (though neither were ever gonna win)

Standard was brilliant, but the judges standing up after every performance was slightly annoying

i think it was an easy week to look good - with the big band

and that was why diana was so good, because she didnt use the band as much as others

daniel to go next week with ruth in the bottom 2

eoghan is still really annoying

[Zetti]

Am gutted Scott went but Daniel deserved to stay

[James Martin]

Wrong result last night ultimately but neither of them were any good.

Diana looks like she could win this right now, and I've never been able to call a clear winner this early, not even in Leona's year.

[Lesley Bee]

I'm glad that the judges did what they were supposed to do and judge purely on the last two perfomances. Daniel had so much passion in his last song and you could tell he was singing from the heart, imo it was his best performance to date

Still love Diana and Laura so much, i really can't decide between them

[claire_louise]

I think Daniel should have gone last night and it annoys me that his wife's death keeps coming up to get him the sympathy vote. I don't deny that he's been through a terrible time, but it's a talent competition and IMO Scott is a better singer and would sell more records. Neither of them were very good last night though, and I did think the right people were in the bottom two.

My favourites last night were JLS, Ruth and Diana. I don't know what it is about JLS...they definitely aren't as polished as they could be, but for some reason they just make me smile.

[Anaya]

JLS are awesome, even when they aren't at their best, I still get entertained by them. They have lots of chemistry, their performances are very natural and they make it look easy and fun. I love to watch them.

And what can I say about Diana that hasn't already been said?? She's so unique and great. Her voice isn't the biggest, but I love it. It's very different, and each week she just comes out and does so well. Each person will have a week where the theme doesn't suit them, some more than 1 week, yet Diana has performed amazingly every time.

Also really like Laura & Ruth (she's just taken off after being in the bottom 2 and that Purple Rain performance).

As for Alexandra, she's got such a great voice and lots of talent, but everything seems so rehearsed and not so natural. She needs to quit mimicking other people and instead just be herself.

[Zetti]

I cant fault Laura or Diana as I love them. I especially love Laura. She is very unique and will go far in the competition. Austin is starting to grate on me so I think he should go next.

[monkeysmoke]

I'm fully behind Diana, she's wicked.

And for some reason she really reminds me of Tessa James (Nicole in H&A)

[claire_louise]

I can't believe Diana managed to pull off singing disco - she was brilliant! Although I had hoped she was going to sing Young Hearts Run Free, as I thought that would be perfect for her. I loved JLS as well, and Laura, Ruth and Alexandra were good, but I hated Eoghan, Daniel, Rachel and Austin. I really hope Daniel or Rachel goes tonight.

[jim6600]

daniel has to go

with rachel in the bottom two with her