X Factor 2008

[Cerise]

JLS were good, Eoghan was good... but Dianna was AMZING How did the judges fault her like that? I thought she was just great.

[HeavenForbid]

Eoghan was AMAZING! I love Diana but this week, I think she was a bit off.

[TachelHolden]

Dianna was brilliant and so was rachel ! Daniel to leave !!!!!!!

[bttb-rox!]

Alexandra's performance was beautiful but quite understated. It was like there was something missing again.

Eoghan was brilliant. I wouldn't go as far as saying he will definitely be in the final; however, he does have a good chance if he keeps doing what he's doing.

The only part of JLS's performance that I enjoyed was when they did 'Hey Jude'. I'm not really sure why they did a medley .

Diana was fantastic, though obviously not as strong this week as she would've been otherwise. But good on her for giving it a go. Go Diana!!!

Daniel really shocked me - I was fully preparing myself for something out of tune or just not interesting, but I loved it!

I was so glad that Rachel finally got the chance to do an Amy Winehouse song. It's that kind of style that really suits her and I feel she's been let down by the majority of the choices up until now.

Ruth was good, but I didn't think it was quite as good as the judges seemed to think it was.

Overall, Daniel, Eoghan and Diana are my favourites for the night .

[claire_louise]

I was so glad that Rachel finally got the chance to do an Amy Winehouse song. It's that kind of style that really suits her and I feel she's been let down by the majority of the choices up until now.

The problem is that it's the only style she can do. Everyone else manages to adapt to different styles each week (admittedly with varying degress of success!) but she's only done two decent performances in the whole series. Her voice is so similar to Amy Winehouse's that there isn't really a gap in the market for her. Who wants to buy a cd of an Amy Winehouse sound-a-like when you could just as easily get the real thing?

[bttb-rox!]

I completely agree with your point that the 'Winehouse style' is the only style Rachel can actually pull off properly.

'Run' is going to number one, isn't it? Please tell me that incredible song will get to number one. That was stunning.

[bttb-rox!]

Daniel's off . I don't really know what to say apart from the world would be a better place if it was full of Daniel's.

[Cerise]

I'm sad because Daniel is a really nice guy but I guess he was never gonna win. What is Rachel on though!?

[princess_in_pink]

Finally. He's a nice guy, but not in a million years would he have won. I liked his sing-off though. In fact I think he outsung Rachel; it seemed like she didn't even try, She seemed cocky. Yes, I know you were up against Daniel, & you're clearly safe, but showing a little modesty won't hurt.

Overall I enjoyed tonight. I was happy to see Diana back. Wasn't too sure of her performance, but under the circumstances she did well. JLS & Ruth were the highlight of the show for me. Ruth nailed the song. She really does deserve to be in the competition. I'm glad the public kept her in. I was also happy with Rachel's performance. After, what was the travesty last week, she redeemed herself. Eoughan [sp?] Does nothing for me. I don't think he is brilliant, like the judges say, & I hope he doesn't make the final. I hope he's is out next week. Oh & Alex, I like her & I actually remembered her this time.

&& Leona! Pure homegrown talent. She was outstanding.

'Run' is going to number one, isn't it? Please tell me that incredible song will get to number one. That was stunning.

Last time I heard, it was going to be released in December, clashing with X Factors' winner single. So she might have some competition.

[Jocy]

Rachel was good last night, I was surprised she was in the bottom to - I think it was a back lash against last week when perhaps she should have been.

Daniel went out on a high which is the best way to go IMO.