~Zoe~ Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 Very happy all my favourites are through, Aiden & Matt & One Direction ! Wrong choice I thought, Nicolo going (I do like Lady Gaga but it was the wrong song choice for him!!) Shocked the public saved Wagner! Did'nt really like Katie, but she did give the better performance tonight in the sing off over FYD I guess Dannii Minogue looked amazing in that Jingle Project D dress, I want it lol
KirstyEkua Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 As much as i don't like Nicolo he didn't deserve to go. I can't believe that Wagner person is still in, it's shocking And yeah firmly on Team Minogue
Ryan Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 As much as i don't like Nicolo he didn't deserve to go. I can't believe that Wagner person is still in, it's shocking And yeah firmly on Team Minogue Are you rolling your eyes at my vote?
halcyon06 Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 Its gotta be Team Minogue this year! And regarding comments made previously about Dannii being 'successful', that may be true, but when you compare her to Simon & Cheryl, she pretty much is the underdog on the panel and always has been (besides Louis of course ).. I think last year people actually began to accept her (including me) and I hope this year will be a repeat of last year. I personally would hate to see Cheryl win again this year- nothing personal against the girl, I do like her, but I still cannot fathom the immense obsession surrounding her, and I would also hate to think that she receives credit for winning the past 2 years..am, hello, she has the best category each year! Maybe you can give her a little credit but, in all fairness, Alexandra and Joe always had brilliant vocalists. I guess if Dannii were to win the same argument would be made, seeing as she has two very strong contenders this year...but hey, I love when the underdog wins.. But thats just my personal opinion! Ok, so I am in love with Aiden!! Omg...I cannot describe it. Matt was amazing too! And of course Mary... go on you good thing! I am so annoyed the judges didnt send home Katie- ok, her vocals are undoubtedly better than FDY's...but I still cant stand the girl. I liked her at her first audition but as the show progressed i developed a serious hatred towards the girl..ok, hatred is a bit strong, but I really cant stand her! I'm sorry love but you'r nowhere near Lady Gaga after one preformance!!.. I was really shocked Dannii and Louis didnt send her home actually.. Have to say, I preferred Dannii's look on saturday over tonights by a mile..and also loved the Louis being put in an awkward position when that calller asked him about bringing Sharon back on the Xtra Factor!
KirstyEkua Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 ^ I loved the Louis thing too, hehe!! Funny how Simon and Cheryl really seemed to be on Dannii's side. I love how diplomatic she's been over it. (And seeing Sharon on Graham Norton i was pretty disgusted and lost all respect i had for her). As much as i don't like Nicolo he didn't deserve to go. I can't believe that Wagner person is still in, it's shocking And yeah firmly on Team Minogue Are you rolling your eyes at my vote? Hahah it seems so! I don't think Dannii can be considered that successful, certainly compared to Cheryl and co. She's struggled and although the British public seem to really love her now (all her magazine awards, women of the year, tv presenter of the year etc) she's not really had an easy time of it. And now she seems to be in a post baby bliss and it's lovely to see and i for one really want her to win! And she does have 3 amazing guys left who can actually sing Glad to see Cheryl calmed down on the tan
halcyon06 Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 ^I was just about to say, she seemed to opt for a more natural look tonight! Less tan and light make-up..
halcyon06 Posted October 10, 2010 Report Posted October 10, 2010 ^I was just about to say, she seemed to opt for a more natural look tonight! Less tan and light make-up..
Slade Posted October 11, 2010 Report Posted October 11, 2010 I personally would hate to see Cheryl win again this year- nothing personal against the girl, I do like her, but I still cannot fathom the immense obsession surrounding her, and I would also hate to think that she receives credit for winning the past 2 years..am, hello, she has the best category each year! I have to agree with this. A hatrick might even be on the cards. I actually think out of the judges Louis might be one of the best simply because at times, he's had so little to work with over the years but knows how to manage people and how to get the best out of them. He also knows EXACTLY which songs to pick for any type of singer. If anyone else had Jedward last year I'm not sure if they would be doing as well as they are at the moment. If Cheryl had the over 28s it would be interesting to see how well she would do but it's not going to happen. I should say I'm surprised at Simon's attitude towards the singers (i.e. not criticizing like he did before) but at the end of the day he's a businessman so he will be thinking of the bucks which is understandable. I think a lot of people in his position would be. I'm not shocked Katie stayed. I said it previously she doesn't have a very strong voice but I think she is marketable and if she did have a record deal before there must be something appealing about her - even though I don't know the circumstances of that. What surprised me was when the decision came down to Lois and he chose Katie, Simon didn't say anything, almost as if he thought that was the right decision. Some people could argue the fair thing would have been to send it to deadlock... Seriously though I thought Katie's performance last night was miles better than the night before so based on that she deserved to go through. I do think she'll struggle over the coming weeks though. Just watching her, she put everything into that performance whereas some of the singers it just comes a lot more naturally. I actually don't think Nicolo deserved to go and would have liked him to stay simply because of the whole controversial element. The problem as confirmed by the judges and the other contestants he has sense of humour that takes a little while to get used to so I'm guessing that some people probably didn't find him very likeable. One think I liked was the fact he was honest about being eliminated so early. Can see a couple of comments above indicating they don't really like Cher. Personally now she's my favourite. She's different, I like the way she dresses and she's not afraid to take risks. For me some of the other singers play it safe but to stand out you have to try and do something out of the ordinary. I do think she was a bit lucky that Cheryl picked her over TreyC but I think Cheryl possibly saw a bit of herself in Cher. I don't think it would have made difference anyway because she still would have got in via the wildcard. I really enjoyed her performance on Saturday but do wonder whether she'll be able to sustain this especially during the later stages of the competition. She's already show once that she's crumbled under pressure (even though she had a throat infection). I'm not going to be able to see her on the next live show as I'll be on holiday so I'll have to make sure I catch up with itv player.
~Zoe~ Posted October 16, 2010 Report Posted October 16, 2010 Good show tonight! Really did'nt like Cher's performance tonight.. totally agreed with Dannii Minogue's comments tonight, that is why she is the best judge, the only honest one out of the lot. Awww... I felt so sorry for Aiden tonight, he's so talented yet, I dont think that was the right song for him! So I hope people pick up that phone & vote for Aiden, would be crazy if he was in the bottom 3 tomorrow night! Matt Cardle Ah he was fantastic tonight, supported him & Aiden from their first audition anyway, but Matt tonight was brilliant Great song choice for him too, one of my favourite songs at the moment! One Direction are just adorable & they were good aswell!
halcyon06 Posted October 17, 2010 Report Posted October 17, 2010 I'm so gutted for Aiden... please, please please vote for him!! If hoe goes tonight it would be a 'travesty' as Louis put it! Anyone else notice the tension between the judges tonight? It was as if they were split into two- Dannii & Louis versus Cheryl & Simon. Everything Dannii and Louis said, Cheryl and Simon disagreed, with Simon laying a blatent attack on Dannii over dancers...wtf! As someone pointed out on twitter when there is something wrong with the dancers for his preformers its Brian Friedmans fault, but when its Paije's performance its Dannii's. Good to see she stood up to him though... Apparently theres a big rift between Cheryl and Louis so maybe thats whats going on. Have to say, Cheryl really annoyed me last night too. I didn't like Cher's performance at all! Mary rocked, as usual though!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.